Jake Paul has built a boxing career on defying expectations, but questions still linger about his legitimacy in the sport. After knocking out former UFC fighters like Ben Askren and Tyron Woodley, and even securing a decision victory over Nate Diaz in their first encounter, skeptics continue to argue that Paul has yet to face a true boxing test. Now, with rumors of a potential rematch or an MMA bout against Diaz, the YouTuber-turned-boxer has another chance to prove his doubters wrong. But will this fight finally cement his status as a real contender, or will Diaz expose Paul’s limits once and for all?
From the beginning, Paul’s boxing journey has been met with skepticism. Critics have accused him of cherry-picking opponents—mostly aging MMA fighters with little boxing experience. While his knockout power and athleticism are undeniable, many believe he has yet to face a high-level boxer in his prime. His most legitimate test came against Tommy Fury, a professional boxer with a traditional background, and Paul fell short, losing via split decision. That loss reignited debates over whether Paul is simply a well-marketed entertainer or a serious fighter.
On the other side, Nate Diaz presents a unique challenge. The former UFC star is known for his durability, cardio, and relentless fighting style. Although Diaz isn’t a pure boxer, he has a lifetime of combat sports experience, including high-profile battles against Conor McGregor, Jorge Masvidal, and Leon Edwards. In their first boxing match, Diaz showcased his toughness but struggled with Paul’s power and size. However, Diaz’s unbreakable will and ability to adapt could make him a dangerous opponent in a potential rematch—especially if he takes the fight more seriously and sharpens his boxing skills.
One of the biggest factors in this rivalry is the possibility of an MMA fight. Paul has teased the idea of stepping into Diaz’s world by competing in MMA under the PFL banner. If that happens, the narrative shifts dramatically. While Paul has a wrestling background from his high school days, he would be stepping into uncharted territory against a Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu black belt like Diaz. A loss in MMA could severely damage Paul’s credibility, while a victory would be a shocking moment that could redefine his career.
Ultimately, this fight—whether in a boxing ring or an MMA cage—represents another opportunity for Jake Paul to prove himself. If he defeats Diaz convincingly in boxing, it might silence some critics, but until he fights an elite boxer, doubts will remain. If he dares to face Diaz in MMA and pulls off an upset, it would be one of the most shocking moments in combat sports history. Either way, Paul thrives on controversy and hype, and this matchup guarantees plenty of both. Whether he finally earns respect or adds more fuel to his doubters’ fire, one thing is certain—Jake Paul knows how to keep the world watching.